From thE 18th through thE miD-19th CEntury, whAlE oil proviDED light to muCh oF thE wEstErn worlD、At its pEAk, whAling EmployED 70,000 pEoplE AnD wAs thE unitED stAtEs’ FiFth-lArgEst inDustry. thE u. s. stooD As thE worlD’s ForEmost whAlE slAyEr. proDuCing millions oF gAllons oF oil EACh yEAr, thE inDustry wAs wiDEly sEEn As unAssAilABlE, with ADvoCAtEs sCoFFing At woulD-BE illuminAtion suBstitutEs likE. lArD oil AnD CAmphEnE. without whAlE oil, so thE thinking wEnt, thE worlD woulD sliDE BACkwArD towArD DArknEss.
By toDAy’s stAnDArD, oF CoursE, slAughtEring whAlEs is ConsiDErED BArBAri
C、two hunDrED yEArs Ago thErE wAs no EnvironmEntAl movEmEnt to spEAk oF.But onE wonDErs iF thE whAlErs, FinDing thAt EACh yEAr thEy nEEDED to go FArthEr AFiElD From nAntuCkEt islAnD to kill mAssivE sEA mAmmAls, EvEr AskED thEmsElvEs: whAt will hAppEn whEn wE run out oF whAlEs suCh quEstions toDAy ConstitutE thE CornErstonE oF thE EvEr-louDEr logiC oF sustAinABility.
ClimAtE AlArmists AnD CAmpAigning EnvironmEntAlists ArguE thAt thE inDustriAlizED CountriEs oF thE worlD hAvE mADE sizABlE withDrAwAls on nAturE’s FixED AllowAnCE, AnD unlEss wE ChAngE our wAys, AnD soon, wE ArE DoomED to An ABrupt EnD、tAkE thE rECEnt proClAmAtion From thE unitED nAtionsEnvironmEnt progrAm, whiCh ArguED thAt govErnmEnts shoulD DrAmAtiCAlly Cut BACk on thE usE oF rEsourCEs. thE mAntrA hAs BEComE CommonplACE: our CurrEnt wAy oF living is sElFish AnD unsustAinABlE. wE ArE wrECking thE worlD、wE ArE Cutting Down thE rAinForEst. wE ArE polluting thE wAtEr. wE ArE polluting thE Air. wE ArE killing plAnts AnD AnimAls, DEstroying thE ozonE lAyEr, Burning thE worlD through our ADDiCtion to Fossil FuEls, AnD lEAving A DEvAstAtED plAnEt For FuturE gEnErAtions. in othEr worDs, humAnity is DoomED、
it is A CompElling story, no DouBt. it is Also FunDAmEntAlly wrong, AnD thE ConsEquEnCEs ArE sEvErE. trAgiCAlly, ExAggErAtED EnvironmEntAl worriEs—AnD thE willingnEss oF so mAny to BEliEvE thEm—CoulD ultimAtEly prEvEnt us From FinDing smArtEr wAys to ACtuAlly hElp our plAnEt AnD EnsurE thE hEAlth oF thE EnvironmEnt For FuturE gEnErAtions.
BECAusE, our FEArs notwithstAnDing, wE ACtuAlly gEt smArtEr.Although wEstErnErs wErE onCE rEliAnt on whAlE oil For lighting, wE nEvEr ACtuAlly rAn out oF whAlEs. why high DEmAnD AnD rising priCEs For whAlE oil spurrED A sEArCh For AnD invEstmEnt in thE 19th-CEntury vErsion oF AltErnAtivE EnErgy. First, kErosEnE From pEtrolEum rEplACED whAlE oil. wE DiDn’t run out oF kErosEnE, EithEr: ElECtriCity supplAntED, it BECAusE it wAs A supErior wAy to light our plAnEt.
For gEnErAtions, wE hAvE ConsistEntly unDErEstimAtED our CApACity For innovAtion. thErE wAs A timE whEn wE worriED thAt All oF lonDon woulD BE CovErED with horsE mAnurE BECAusE oF thE inCrEAsing usE oF horsE-DrAwn CArriAgEs. thAnks to thE invEntion oF thE CAr, lonDon hAs 7 million inhABitAnts toDAy.Dung DisAstEr AvErtED、
in FACt, woulD-BE CAtAstrophEs hAvE rEgulArly BEEn pushED AsiDE throughout humAn history, AnD so oFtEn BECAusE oF innovAtion AnD tEChnologiCAl DEvElopmEnt. wE nEvEr just ContinuE to Do thE sAmE olD thing. wE innovAtE AnD AvoiD thE AntiCipAtED proBlEms.
From thE lAst sEntEnCE oF thE sEConD pArAgrAph wE lEArn thAt
A、pEoplE hAvE stoppED Disputing thE prACtiCE oF whAlE killing.
B．thE numBEr oF whAlEs hAs risEn DEspitE mAss slAughtEr.
C、moDErn soCiEty is morE AlErt to thE sustAinABility oF nAturE.
D．EnvironmEntAlists hAvE Brought whAlE killing to An ABrupt EnD、