impressed you as a unit; you did not see it as a col- lection of shapes or forms. This, of course, means Line that the shapes and volumes within the sculpture (5) itself were coordinated so successfully that the viewer was affected emotionally. It is entirely valid to ask how, from a purely artis- tic point of view, this unity was achieveD、And we must also inquire whether there is a recurrent pat- (10) tern or rules or a plastic language and vocabulary which is responsible for the powerful communica- tion of emotion which the bestAfrican sculpture achieves. If there is such a pattern or rules, are these rules applied consciously or instinctively to (15) obtain so many works of such high artistic quality It is obvious from the study of art history that an intense and unified emotional experience, such as theChristianCredo of theByzantine or 12th or 13th centuryEurope, when expressed in art forms, gave (20) great unity, coherence, and power to art.But such an integrated feeling was only the inspirational element for the artist, only the starting point of the creative act. The expression of this emotion and its realization in the work could be done only with dis- (25) cipline and thorough knowledge of the craft.And theAfrican sculptor was a highly trained workman. He started his apprenticeship with a master when a child, and he learned the tribal styles and the use of tools and the nature of woods so thoroughly that his (30) carving became whatBoas calls "motor action." He carved automatically and instinctively. TheAfrican carver followed his rules without thinking of them; indeed, they never seem to have been formulated in words.But such rules existed, (35) for accident and coincidence cannot explain the common plastic language ofAfrican sculpture. There is too great a consistency from one work to another. Yet, although theAfrican, with amazing insight into art, used these rules, I am certain that (40) he was not conscious of them. This is the great mystery of such a traditional art: talent, or the abili- ty certain people have, without conscious effort, to follow the rules which later the analyst can discov- er only from the work of art which has already (45) been createD、 The information in the passage suggests that anAfrican carver might best be compared to a A、chef following a recipe B.fluent speaker ofEnglish who is just beginning to study French C.batter who hits a home run in his or her first baseball game D.concert pianist performing a well-rehearsed concerto E、writer who is grammatically expert but stylistically uncreative